106 N. Main St Fairport: Opening Summer of '26! Check back for updates. In the meantime please allow us to briefly introduce ourselves! Owners and operators of the Webster Jewelry and coin and Penfield gold and coin for the past 17 years, we are proud to be opening our newest location here in Fairport NY! We are well known for paying the very best prices for scrap gold and silver, jewelry, coins and bullion, We also offer a very family friendly atmoshpere and a comfortable setting. There is never any pressure to sell, evaluations are always free and every person who walks into our shop gets treated with the utmost respect! Kindness matters! We are not doing our job unless you leave our shop with a smile on your face! If you have any questions, please call us at 585-755-8358
Why Work With Us?
We consitantly pay higher than any shop in western NY. We have very close long standing relationships with refineries across NYS and a large retail following. Having a large number of outlets for our metals, coins and fine jewelry, we can in turn, pay you much higher than a shop who is just simply sending off to a melter for 80% of melt.
We also sell! We sell coins, estate jewelry, vintage pieces, investment bullion, coin supplies, antiques and collectibles as well.
We are not a pawn shop. We do not give loans. We do not buy big store big box items or gift cards, electronics or tools.
